Friday, 11 December 2015

Personal Reflection - Evaluation

What went well?
  • Aesthetic quality: My Esting looked good after I finished polishing and adding the last few details and corrections.  I was able to correct the colour problems I had with the tools on Premier Pro to make the clips look like they were all filmed in the same time frame.  It also helped me hide the fact that the lighting was different in a few frames.  I filmed my work backwards because since my Esting was about a jigsaw puzzle I knew I would have difficulty putting the pieces together whilst filming.  Filming the puzzle altogether first and then taking them apart proved to be the best option to prevent complications.
  • Technical quality: I was able to overcome the technical difficulty of having the wrong type of clips to use on Premier Pro.  I received advice and help on how to change these type of files into JPEGs so that I was able to fit them in the timeframe of my work.
  • Creative quality: Even though my idea was simple, I was able to interpret different ideas on how my puzzle pieces travelled across the room and fitted together.  I used a box covered in E4 logos for the pieces to “fall out” of and using blue tack behind each piece I was able to make them climb down the table and up the wall.  Using a white wall to put all my pieces together provided the perfect background and lighting. 



What didn’t go so well?
  • Aesthetic quality: The only thing I didn’t like the looks of in my Esting was my lighting. I spent a few lessons trying to make the lighting all match up so it wouldn’t look so jumpy and rushed.  I tried to use clay in part of my production though that proved to be difficult seeing as they wouldn’t stick to the wall very well and I found myself losing filming time trying to fix this.  In the end I took the clay out of my Esting.
  • Technical quality: The problem with having the wrong kind of clips that wouldn’t work on Premier Pro proved to be my biggest problem.  I had issues with this for about three days because even though I changed the clips (with assistance) they would disappear or turn back into the wrong file.  I ended up beating this problem by putting the new right kind of clips into a different folder so that I could the carry on with my work.
  • Creative quality: To make the box fall off the table I found it difficult to show thing without having to have my own arm in the shot.  I was able to find someone to crouch down out of the shot and move the box for me, to develop the illusion it was moving off the table by itself.  This took many attempts but when I finally succeeded it looked creative and was work the time.




What would you do differently?
  • Aesthetic quality: I would have made sure I filmed the puzzle pieces on the wall on the same day so that I would have kept the right kind of lighting and camera angle.  I would have also made sure I repeated this with the over shots so it would flow better and look more pleasing to the eye.  The lighting was too patchy but I was able to reduce this problem the best I could.
  • Technical quality: I would have double checked that the camera would have taken shots that would come up as JPEG files.  This would have saved me a lot of time and I would have been able to work more on the lighting problems and maybe I could have even re-filmed some of the shots.
  • Creative quality: My idea was very simple and I wish I came up with more ideas to uses the puzzle pieces more creatively.  For example, I would have liked to make them do more movements instead of following each other in a straight line down a table, across the floor and up the wall.  I could have done more with the box such as used the paper with the logos on it to move up towards the box and wrap itself around it.  There was lack of time and too many shots to do this.

I experienced some constraints when making my Esting, for example but there were no legal issues or financial difficulties.  Sometimes I needed more space to video my Esting so I would have to sometimes wait until after the lesson when the room was empty.  We had about three weeks to film which included editing too.  I had problems with my pictures not being the right file to use on Premier Pro so I had to film in my spare time.  I managed myself to work at lunchtimes and after the lesson so I could get the filming done and concentrate on editing. 

I conformed to the guidance set-up on the E4 Esting competition’s website.  I had a YouTube account, I submitted an entry on my own (I could have been part of a group), am over the age of 16 and was a resident living in the UK, did one entry (one entry per person was required) and kept it 10 seconds long, included the E4 logo, used the supplied music we were restricted to and my work wasn’t obscene, indecent, defamatory, unlawful, offensive and it didn’t infringe the copyright, intellectual property right, moral right or any other third party right.  I checked that my video followed all of these guidelines which I also checked with my teacher.

Here is some of the feedback I received.  As you can see it is mainly about the lighting as the final outcome of my work proved to be a little bit dark.  I did have problems with lighting in my work which also proved difficult to fix.


I also received feedback from my survey on Survey Monkey which i emailed alongside with a video of my Esting.  Most people who took the survey were male and most people said it was smooth and it flowed very well.  Again the feedback I received said that the lighting could be improved and one person stated that I could have used a less plainer background.  



I have learnt that I had to work hard to meet deadlines in order to get my work up to a good standard.  It didn’t necessarily mean I had to be less creative because I didn’t want to make a complicated or inappropriate idea based on anything that already existed. 

I think I would be a suitable candidate for working within the media industry where I would have to work to a specific brief because I think I proved using my Esting work as an example that I was able to meet deadlines and successfully create a good piece of work.  It would be an option to pursue animation for me but I would have to see all of my other options first.


No comments:

Post a Comment